Over the years, I’ve realized that my job requires a few skills that nobody really talks about, but everyone expects me to have. One of them comes into play at that exact moment when everyone is stumped, and someone says, “Kit, any good ideas?”
And then everyone turns to look at me and blinks.
People just love to ask the creative in the room to find the way out of a dead end.
Spitballing.* Not exactly a skill you’d write on a resume (although I don’t have a resume anymore anyway), but an essential one nonetheless.
A spitball moment reminds you that being a creative is both a blessing and a curse. You’re getting paid for your creative ideas, but that means you’re often expected to have them ready at any time, including in a group setting with all eyes on you.
I’ve had a few meetings go like this lately, so I used them for some off-the-cuff research. The following is essentially my personal toolkit of spitballing techniques, which have helped me countless times to come up with an idea on the spot (including taglines for The Gap! More on that below). As always, take what you like and leave the rest.
*For the sake of this newsletter, I looked up the term “spitball.” Much like “moist,” it’s awful, and like many a metaphor, it comes mostly from baseball: Someone somewhere once moistened a baseball with their saliva (!!!) to create an unpredictable pitch. Again: ew.
01. Reply to the “Any creative ideas?” question with your own questions.
If someone asks me to spitball ideas, and I’m immediately drawing a blank, it’s not because I don’t have them; it’s because I need to know more to get started.
So I often start by asking what problem they’re trying to solve. Or I ask what the end goal is. Or I ask why they think they’re stuck. Generally, opening the discussion up a bit gives me more information to inspire the ideas, but it also has an added benefit: it buys me time to allow my brain to come online.
02. Some of your ideas will be bad. If it makes you feel better, confess.
Last year, an agency paid me to think up holiday taglines for The Gap. Very, very last-minute. They tasked me to come up with as many ideas as I could in three hours.
I sat down and started filling a blank Google Doc with dozens and dozens of ideas. Most of them were awful; a few were astronomically bad. But three of them made it to the pitch meeting.
That’s wild when you think about it: not one, but three of my spitballed taglines made it to the higher-ups at a massive brand. And I came up with them all in under three hours.
I think as creatives we often fear the workshopping part of coming up with ideas — we want to hide our work until it feels fully realized. When you’re asked to spitball, it’s easy to freeze up and think: “I need only great ideas or they’ll think I’m a hack.”
My workaround has been to warn folks that I’m going to share all sorts of ideas, including some bad ideas. And then I just go.
It’s all very “spaghetti at the wall,” but something always sticks.
03. Think laterally.
Similar to “thinking outside the box,” but IMO far more useful. There’s a technical term for this, which I learned way back in my content strategy days: comparative analysis.
Most of us know what a competitive analysis is (looking at your competition in the field, deciding what they’ve overlooked or done poorly, and doing it better), but the best on-the-spot ideas often come from talking about ideas you liked from another field or place.
So many people are doing cool things. So many people throughout history have done cool things.
I've borrowed from restaurants to pitch fashion brands; I once turned a Dutch Masters painting I saw in a museum into an ad campaign that ran on taxis and billboards.
When you’re facing a blank wall, take a side door. Instead of thinking about the situation you’re in, ask yourself: Where have I seen something like this somewhere unexpected? And what did they do with it? How did they do it? Why did I like it so much?
04. Invite participation (the old “Yes, and”).
Turn the “Any ideas?” moment into an improvised workshop. I’m talking about crowdsourcing, baby.
When I’m feeling wild, I’ll suggest everyone just take five minutes in silence to jot down a few ideas. More often, I’ll start us off with a couple of ideas and ask, “Does anyone have any ideas on how to make that more exciting/interesting/meaningful?”
Some of the best creative ideas come from people who wouldn’t describe themselves as “creatives.” Let them cook.
05. Keep ideas you admire on file.
I have stacks and stacks of categorized Instagram collections on different topics, including one for this very newsletter. I also have collections for different clients who have specific content/branding needs. Meanwhile, over in my inbox, I have a folder called SWIPE FILE, where I save marketing emails I admire for future inspiration. When you’re spitballing, it’s insanely helpful to be able to say, “You know I saved something just last week that I loved…let me find it.”
06. Read a lot. Have coffee and wine with smart, weird people often.
This is the long game part of my spitballing toolkit, but the more you take in, the more you fill up the well for spontaneous creative ideas. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve found myself in a meeting, tasked with coming up with a creative solution, only to think: “I was just talking to a ceramicist friend about something like this,” or “I just read something about this.”
Ideas don't exist in a vacuum. You've got to take them in constantly to produce your own instantly.
07. The answer can be: I don’t know yet.
A friend and I were talking about our stress tolerance recently, and I found myself thinking about how my response to creative requests is similar. As she put it: “It's like once I fill up, there's no more space until I get to frolic and be a potato to recharge.”
When your brain is fully roasted, sometimes you’ve just got to be the potato for a bit. You don’t have to say yes to everything, remember?
That’s when “Oh, that’s interesting; let me think more on that and get back to you with some ideas” is not only a perfectly acceptable answer but the right one.
Spitball when you can; potato when you must. The ideas will come. They always do.
If someone forwarded this email to you and you liked it, I’d appreciate it if you’d subscribe.
Find me at kitwarcholstudio.com and kitwarchol.com. What should I cover next? Submit your burning questions (anonymous is fine) here.
And if you’ve read this far and love getting insights from the lives of others, here’s what everyone cool is reading these days.
